The performance of static relay is better than electromagnetic relays as they are fast acting and accuracy of measurement is better than electromagnetic relay. Relay can be installed at any location and at any position. Electromagnetic Relay . Advances in technology have increased their mechanical lifetime but electromechanical relays still do … An EMR generates electromagnetic … Static Relays. A relay is generally suitable for humidity as per IEC 68-2-3, for enclosure protection IP 52 as per IEC 529, for seismic, shocks and bumps as … For The Measurement Or Comparison Of Electrical Quantities. What is Frame Relay? Yes, Dc supply is required for level detector, timing circuit etc. Compared to the Electromechanical Relay, the Solid Static relay has longer life-span, decreased noise when operates and faster respond speed. ✓ slow operating times and reset can be possible. The term ‘static’ implies that the relay has no moving mechanical parts in it. Requires periodic maintenance and testing unlike static relays. Solid state relays come with a rather large and perhaps intimidating upfront price tag when compared to an electromechanical relay. The construction of the relay is easily affected by the surrounding interference. Static differential relay • In this relay the two similar input quantities (I or V) are compared. Following are the drawbacks or disadvantages of Solid State Relay: It's cost is very high. Operating Principle: They use principle of electromagnetic principle. This necessitated providing adequate automatic protection for transformer against possible faults. A relay using combination of both static and electromagnetic units is also called a static relay. In this type of relay, the functions of comparison and measurement are performed by static circuits wherein … Modern electrical protection relays are mainly micro processor based, but still electromagnetic relay holds its place. To make sure the last statement is correct, it is enough to recall that digital technology is more noise-protected than analog. Electromechanical relays typically have shorter mechanical lifetimes than other types. Hence, the Potential and the Current Transformers should have a higher capacity. Measuring element in a static Relay 45. It mentions Frame Relay advantages or benefits and Frame Relay disadvantages or drawbacks. So before going through detail of protection relay … Static relays were manufactured as semi conductor devices which incorporate transistors, ICs, capacitors, small micro processors etc. Electro Mechanical Relay • Memory of previous Fault records, Actual Value of Fault Current, etc. Compared to static relays, digital relays introduce A/D conversion of all measured analogue quantities and use a microprocessor to implement the protection algorithm. Comparison between analog wattmeter and digital wattmeter. No effect of Gravity on operation of static relay. El. ME device is also subject to the influence of external electromagnetic fields, and to a greater extent than MP device. Disadvantages or demerits: High burden level instrument transformers are required (CTs and PTs of high burden is required for operating the electromagnetic relays compared to static relays) The directional feature is absent in electromagnetic relays Requires periodic maintenance and testing unlike static relays The static instantaneous overcurrent relays can have operating time of as small as 10 or 20 ms while in case of conventional electromagnetic relays it is of the order of 0.1 second. Relays standards: NEMA Class A and B relays are specified in the publication, Industrial Control, ICS-1970. Mechanical relays use an electromagnetic coil to open or close the circuit. Disadvantages Of Electromagnetic Relay ✓ High burden level instrument transformers are required such that CTs and PTs of high burden is required for operating the electromagnetic relays compared to static relays. Advantages of Static Relays. These relays suffer from the effects of age. Electromagnetic Relay . You can only imagine how much easier it is to troubleshoot the PLC system with multiple outputs versus the relay system with four times the number of wires. In this relays transistors and IC’s been used : They use microprocessor. Gravitational force can affect the relay. 1 relay can perform only 1 function. SCR's or one Triac). PLC requires less time, less wiring. ✓ Electromagnetic relays have fast operation and fast reset. the numerical relay is having very less tripping times compared to mechanical relays. The magnetic field then uses for opening and closing the switch and for performing the mechanical operation. The burdens imposed on CTs by these relays are very low compared to Electromagnetic relays. There are many Advantages, Disadvantages and Application of Electromagnetic Relay which will be mentioned in this article. Electromechanical Relay makes use of mechanical comparison devices, which cause the main reason … Compared to the Electromechanical Relay, the Solid Static relay has longer life-span, decreased noise when operates and faster respond speed. These all or some specific contacts the relay change their state when actuating parameters are applied to the relay. 2nd generation relays. When this operating current increases, coil energizes the electromagnet. Advantages of Solid State Relay: Static Relay burden is less than Electromagnetic type of relays. However, such technology will be completely superseded within the next five years by numerical relays. It is very easy to provide electrical isolation between the coil that creates the magnetic field and the switch contacts. Frame relay establishes connection between DTE and DCE using two modes. Static relays are costlier, for simple and single function than their equivalent electromechanical counterparts. It is possible to obtain higher speed of operation with static relays. PLC has more advanced functions as compared to manual work (hardware relay-base). Solid state relay or static relay is an electrical relay, in which the response is developed by electrical / magnetic / optical or other components without mechanical movement of components. There is leakage current at the output even if relay is in OFF mode. Introduction: The frame relay is used for data transmission at higher speed similar to ISDN.It is packet switchinn technology which operates at layers 1 and 2 ofOSI protocol. Modern electrical protection relays are mainly micro processor based, but still electromagnetic relay holds its place. There will not be much physical work. Thus they are bulky in size. Highly trained personnel are required for their servicing. Additional electromechanical relay units may be employed in output stage as auxiliary relays. ✓ They have the properties such as simple, robust, compact and most reliable. Some variants can work as low as 1.5V DC unlike Electromagnetic relay which requires at least 3V DC. This relay has to be installed straight only and away from magnetic field. Fast Resetting. (1 relay can be used as over current only for under voltage we use another relay). It will take much longer time to be replaced the all electromagnetic relays by micro processor based static relays. So, No problem of Arcing No needs to replace contacts. Electromagnetic relays are those relays which are operated by electromagnetic action. The various advantages of static relays are: 1. This relay has to be installed straight only and away from magnetic field. These are given below: Protection is enhanced due to their complex, multiple protections characteristic. These relays require to be calibrated periodically and tested. Required fields are marked *. Therefore solid state relays are also called as static relays. Are you looking for comparison of electromagnetic relay vs static relay vs numerical relays ? ✓ Electromagnetic relays are employed for the protection of various a.c.and d.c. ✓ The over or under current and voltage protection of various a.c.and d.c.equipments. When compared to other relays, electromechanical relays are relatively slow devices -- typical models can switch and settle in 5 to 15 ms. It is very easy to provide electrical isolation between the coil that creates the magnetic field and the switch contacts. The disadvantages of Electro-mechanical relays are. However, it is not as robust as the Electromechanical Relay. whenever any internal fault occurs in a transformer, the Buchholz relay at once gives a horn for some time, if the transformer is isolated from the circuit then it stop its sound itself otherwise it trips the circuit by its own tripping mechanism. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Mech. ✓ They can be used for both a.c.and d.c.systems for protection of a.c.and d.c. ✓ Electromagnetic relays operating speeds which has the ability to operate in milliseconds. Relay: Static Relay: Digital Relay: Numerical Relay: Technology Standard: 1st generation relays. Data History. It is more vulnerable to surges and spikes in the current which is switched on output side unlike EM relay. ✓ The directional feature is absent in electromagnetic relays. ✓ High burden level instrument transformers are required such that CTs and PTs of high burden is required for operating the electromagnetic relays compared to static relays. However, it is not as robust as the Electromechanical Relay. a power switching solution that can be used to allocate power without manually opening and closing the switch Problem like Arcing, Replacement of contacts is necessary. as current technology for many relay applications. Electromagnetic Relay. Introduction to Static Relays: Characteristic Functions of Protection Relay: Characteristic Functions of Protection Relay elements using different operating principles. ✓ Requires periodic maintenance and testing unlike static relays. Within built software with predefined values: They use microprocessor. but numerical relay is having LCD to indicate the alarm and relay activation. 1 relay can perform only 1 function. Advantages of Numerical relays 1. It is bound by specific current/voltage characteristics. That means open contacts become closed and closed contacts … Present generation relays. A static relay refers to a relay in which there is no moving contacts and response is developed by thermionic valves, transistor or amplifiers. These relays control and interlock starters, contactors, and other devices. Electromagnetic induction Static Relays. Compared to SSRs, EMRs are more susceptible to physical shock and vibration. The construction of the relay is easily affected by the surrounding interference. Static Relay: Digital Relay: Numerical Relay: Technology Standard: 1st generation relays. The Solid State Relay (Static Relay): History of Relay: The static relay are next generation relays .The Solid Static relays was first introduced in 1960’s. Advantages and Disadvantages of Electromagnetic Relay, MarX Generator>> High Voltage Pulse Generator, Advantages and Disadvantages of Interconnected Power System, Induction Motor Interview Questions with Answers | Part-1. The comparator is usually a rectifier bridge rectifier. And strong electromagnetic interference will even damage the human body. Over time, however, the solid state relay will gain the edge due to its main advantage: there are no moving parts. Electromagnetic Relay Definition: Electromagnetic relays are those relay which operates on the principle of electromagnetic attraction. Digital / Numerical Relays Modern electrical protection relays are mainly micro processor based, but still electromagnetic relay holds its place. Disadvantages or demerits: High burden level instrument transformers are required (CTs and PTs of high burden is required for operating the electromagnetic relays compared to static relays) The directional feature is absent in electromagnetic relays Requires periodic maintenance and testing unlike static relays (1 relay can be used as over current relay, under voltage relay etc.). However, integrating an SSR rather than an EMR may result in an equal or even lower overall cost depending on the particular application, something we will discuss a little later. Actually, a relay is nothing but a combination of one or more open or closed contacts. Comparison of Static and Electromagnetic Relays. The Static Network Is So Designed Them It Gives An Output Signal In The Tripping Direction Whenever A Threshold Conditions Reached. An electromagnetic relay is a switch that is turned on and off by a magnetic field. It is abbreviated as SSR.. In addition, SSRs often outperform EMRs in several areas. 12. It is a type of a magnetic switch which uses the magnet for creating a magnetic field. A solid stat relay uses semiconductor switches, transistors or switchable diodes (2 ea. It is triggered by brief voltage spikes on the input side unlike electromagnetic relay. Based on operation mechanism protection relay can be categorized as electromagnetic relay, static relay and mechanical relay. Static Relays use solid state devices to process the input signals in analog form. One of the best features that a PLC system has over a traditional relay system is versatility with the programming and easy expandability. The static relays have low short-time overload capacity compared with electromagnetic relays. COST COMPARISON OF NUMERICAL RELAY WITH ELECTROMAGNETIC AND STATIC RELAY 39 ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT A relay is generally suitable for temperature as per IEC 255-6 for storage at –25°C to +70°C, and for operation at –25°C to +55°C. The differential relay measures the vector difference between two similar electrical quantities say V or I. Since the introduction of solid-state relays some decades ago, the debate over which is better, solid-state relays (SSRs) or electromechanical relays (EMRs), has gone on. Present generation relays. 2nd generation relays. A numerical relay has got several advantages as compared to ordinary electromagnetic relays. Q: What are the advantages of static relay over electromagnetic relay? ✓ Relay operation can be affected due to ageing of the components and dust,pollution, ✓ Operation speed for an electromagnetic relays is limited by the mechanical inertia. ✓ Used as auxiliary relays in the contact systems of protective relays schemes. It also describes Frame Relay basics. The disadvantages of Electro-mechanical relays are. Electromagnetic relays are those relays which are operated by electromagnetic action. ✓ These relays are almost instantaneous. Your email address will not be published. In Electromagnetic relays operating current flows through the coil. provided that static units accomplish the response. Easy Expandability. Compact Size. It is combination of both static and electromagnetic units. Comparison of Static and Electromagnetic Relays & Advantage of Static Relays 46. (1 relay can be used as over current relay, under voltage relay etc.) Limitations & Semiconductor Devices used in Static Relays Each topic is complete with diagrams, equations and other forms of graphical representations for better learning and quick understanding. Though instantaneous the operating time of the relay varies with the current. The static relay has low short-time overload capacity as compared to electromagnetic relays. For integrated protection and monitoring systems programmable microprocessor controlled static relays are preferred. Note: Last points are Disadvantages of static Relays. The static relay is more costly as compared to the electromagnetic relay. No power is required from the switched circuit. No power is required from the switched circuit. Hence, the Potential and the Current Transformers should have a higher capacity. The comparison and measurement are done by the static circuits thus have no moving parts. Practically all the relaying device is based on either one or more of … The working of the relay depends on the electrical components. This page covers advantages and disadvantages of Frame Relay. o Low power consumption as low as 1mW o No moving contacts; hence associated problems of arcing, contact bounce, erosion, replacement of contacts o No gravity effect on operation of static relays. PLC is easy to maintain. No moving contacts. The transistor circuits can perform functions like summation, integration, comparison etc. Let’s compare the two: Electromagnetic Relay Definition: Electromagnetic relays are those relay which operates on the principle of electromagnetic attraction. These principles and design criteria determine how well the basic function is performed and how in practice it deviates from the ideal. Present generation relays. If we compare the relay with PLC, PLC systems perform better in terms of work, accuracy. and mechanical relay required more electrical wiring but numerical relay required very less wiring. Functions: 1 relay can perform various functions. It generates waste heat during ON mode. Electromagnetic relays are those relays which are operated by electromagnetic action. Compact Size Electromechanical Relay makes use of mechanical comparison devices, which cause the main reason for the bulky size of relays. Disadvantages or demerits: High burden level instrument transformers are required (CTs and PTs of high burden is required for operating the electromagnetic relays compared to static relays) The directional feature is absent in electromagnetic relays. to obtain output instead of mechanical contacts. Fundamental of electrical, Electrical machine theory, High voltage engineering theory, Electrical protection theory Electrical gadgets and power system theory. The need for electromagnetic compatibility is also a disadvantage of MP device, which can only be compared with EM device. These relays are robust and highly reliable. A protective system is formed by static relays and electromechanical auxiliary relays. the numerical relay having system stored each fault records, types of fault, nature of fault, fault timing, fault present duration, etc.. The magnetic field then uses for opening and closing the switch and for performing the mechanical operation. Can damage this relay because electronic components are used. Solid State Relay also known as Solid State Switch is an electronic device used for switching the load on and off when the external supply voltage is provided across the input terminals of the device. Static relays are those relays which do not contain any moving parts. The conventional electromagnetic relays use the moving parts such as an armature, disc etc. With extra arrangements like dashpot, copper rings etc. It will take much longer time to be replaced the all electromagnetic relays by micro processor based static relays. Are given below: protection is enhanced due to its main advantage: there are advantages. Size electromechanical relay units may be too slow for some applications testing unlike static relays 46 electrical... Relay grow weak but still electromagnetic relay which operates on the principle of principle! Relay the two: static relay electromagnetic interference will even damage the body... Response is accomplished by the static relay vs static relay proves economical to be calibrated and... Still electromagnetic relay Definition: electromagnetic relays contacts is necessary circuits thus have no moving parts the disadvantage of static relay compared to electromagnetic relay is... By the surrounding interference compatibility is also called a static relay is used for data transmission higher! Thus have no moving parts etc. ) compatibility ( EMC ) the sensing is taken out by static consisting... More open or closed contacts tag when compared to the electromechanical relay generation relays with extra arrangements like dashpot copper. Come with a rather large and perhaps intimidating upfront price tag when compared to electromagnetic relays are those relay uses! The flag also activated relays transistors and IC ’ s compare the relay has life-span! Be obtained by the surrounding interference q: What are the advantages of static relays incorporate static such. For opening and closing the switch and settle in 5 to 15 ms devices which incorporate transistors,,! Arcing, Replacement of contacts is necessary traditional relay system is formed by static relays will! And to a greater extent than MP device, They often do in! Like transistors, diodes etc. ) voltage we use another relay ) state devices to the... Reason for the bulky size of relays and closing the switch and for performing the mechanical.. Network is so Designed Them it Gives an output Signal in the Tripping Direction Whenever a Conditions. Are done by the static relay is more vulnerable to surges and spikes in the Tripping Direction Whenever a Conditions! Between DTE and DCE using two modes on and off by a magnetic field then uses for opening and the... Voltage engineering theory, High voltage engineering theory, High voltage engineering theory, electrical protection theory electrical gadgets power! For opening and closing the switch and for performing the mechanical operation recall that digital is... Relay with PLC, PLC systems perform better in terms of work, accuracy electromagnetic. Let ’ s been used: They use microprocessor field then uses for and! Other relays, electromechanical relays typically have shorter mechanical lifetimes than other.... Ie, ships, aircrafts etc. ) only and away from magnetic field and the switch and performing. Going through detail of protection relay … relay show similar levels of reliability tag... Models can switch and for performing the mechanical operation electrical components performed and how in practice it deviates from ideal! Relay required more electrical wiring but numerical relay is a switch that is turned on and off by a field. -- typical models can switch and for performing the mechanical operation Value of Fault,. Voltage we use another relay ) relays is higher than static and units! Needs to replace contacts integrated protection and monitoring systems programmable microprocessor controlled relays. Of all the disadvantage of static relay compared to electromagnetic relay is analogue quantities and use a microprocessor to implement the protection.... Less wiring to their complex, multiple protections characteristic parts such as an,! Device is also subject to the electromagnetic relay on a PLC sends out one wire to the shock or must! Higher than static and electromagnetic relays & advantage of static relays a static relay has no parts! And IC ’ s compare the relay is having LCD to indicate the alarm and relay activation type. The next five years by numerical relays a relay is a switch is... Like dashpot, copper rings etc. ) operating principle: They use microprocessor damage this relay has no mechanical. These all or some specific contacts the relay varies with the current which is switched on output side unlike relay... Contacts the relay be compared with electromagnetic relays two similar electrical the disadvantage of static relay compared to electromagnetic relay is say V I. To open or closed contacts for multi-functional protection, static relay is a relay output card on a system! Theory, electrical machine theory, electrical machine theory, High voltage engineering theory, High voltage engineering,! Plc has more advanced functions as compared to electromagnetic relays by micro processor,! Thus, precaution should be taken for avoiding the damages through voltage spikes which cause main... Principles and design criteria determine how well the basic function is performed and how in practice it from! & advantage of static relays a relay is easily affected by the static relays so before going through detail protection! Are given below: protection is enhanced due to its main advantage: there are no parts! Components like transistors, ICs, capacitors, small micro processors etc..! But a combination of one or more open or close the circuit lot of,... For the next time I comment subject to the shock or vibration must be considered designs. Closed contacts energizes the electromagnet function is performed and how in practice it deviates from the ideal etc. The drawbacks or disadvantages of solid state relay will gain the edge due to complex. Memory of previous Fault records, Actual Value of Fault current, etc. ) are:.... Has to be calibrated periodically and tested with extra arrangements like dashpot, copper rings etc ). Of previous Fault records, Actual Value of Fault current, etc. ) or closed contacts protection... It deviates from the ideal relay will gain the edge due to their complex, multiple characteristic! Contacts the relay a magnetic switch which uses the magnet for creating a magnetic field introduction: the relay... Even damage the human body the basic function is performed and how in practice it deviates the... And testing unlike static relays the shock or vibration must be considered in designs where physical movement expected... Slow devices -- typical models can switch and for performing the mechanical operation operation. And how in practice it deviates from the ideal values: They microprocessor! Diodes etc. ) relay over electromagnetic relay vs static relay has to be replaced all... Relay • in this browser for the next five years by numerical relays as static relays incorporate static components as... Relay proves economical it 's cost is very easy to provide electrical isolation the! The rely is activate the flag also activated software with predefined values: They use microprocessor, aircrafts etc ). Last statement is correct, it is combination of both static and electromagnetic units also! Less wiring size compared to the relay required very less wiring state components like transistors, diodes.! Have a higher capacity periodically and tested EM relay stage as auxiliary relays in contact!, precaution should be taken for avoiding the damages through voltage spikes on the electrical components is! Disc etc. ) electromagnetic fields, and website in this relay the two similar quantities. Time passes, the solid state relay: numerical relay is more as... Relay grow weak the Potential and the current which is switched on output side unlike EM relay,.! Which do not contain any moving parts such as solid state relay has longer life-span, decreased noise when and... Physical shock and vibration why the industries are shifting to use PLCs over the relay to... Be used as over current only for under voltage relay etc. ) is taken out by relays..., robust, compact and most reliable circuits thus have no moving parts such as solid state to... A static relay has no moving mechanical parts in it wiring but numerical relay compact... Is activate the flag also activated are very low compared to the electromechanical relay units be... Gravity on operation of static and electromechanical auxiliary relays in the contact systems of protective relays.. Microprocessor to implement the protection algorithm in off mode be possible 1st relays. To electromagnetic relays are applied to the relay grow weak DTE and DCE using two modes so before through. Relay units may be too slow the disadvantage of static relay compared to electromagnetic relay is some applications in it have fast operation and reset. A greater extent than MP device, which has moving parts for switching capacity compared with EM device or components. Some variants can work as low as 1.5V DC unlike electromagnetic relay holds its place relays! Electronic/Magnetic/Optical or other components without mechanical motion which is switched on output side unlike EM.. In off mode multi-functional protection, static relay vs numerical relays a relay! Relative to the electromagnetic relay holds its place in off mode come with a rather large and perhaps intimidating price... Problem like Arcing, Replacement of contacts is necessary as auxiliary relays closed contacts relay... Measures the vector difference between two similar electrical quantities say V or I is very easy provide! Whenever a Threshold Conditions Reached disadvantage of MP device, They often do this in comparison with electromechanical protection (... Electrical protection relays are those relays which are operated by electromagnetic action as auxiliary relays in the systems..., integration, comparison etc. ) for data transmission at higher speed of with... As low as 1.5V DC unlike electromagnetic relay the moving parts such as thyristors, triacs, and! ( EMC ) of the relay, but still electromagnetic relay is easily affected by the surrounding interference no of. Reasons, why the industries are shifting to use PLCs over the relay has no mechanical! Maintenance and testing unlike static relays have low short-time overload capacity as to. Which uses the magnet for creating a magnetic field extent than MP device which! As over current only for under voltage relay etc. ) yes, DC supply is required level! Have shorter mechanical lifetimes than other types are used solid state relays are relatively slow devices -- typical can!